AI, My Bracket… and Why Advice Still Wins

John Anderson

AI, My Bracket… and Why Advice Still Wins

Way back, it seems like the Stone Age, I had convinced myself I had found an easy way around some of my college math requirements. I took a bunch of computer programming classes.  At the time, and I have no idea if that is the case now, programming was new enough that it lived in the math department.  So instead of Trig, advanced calculus, etc., I took BASIC, PL1, COBOL, and Pascal.  It seemed like a smart move.  I even remember one of my first “end of year” projects.  I built a program in BASIC that prompted the user to input data, and it would generate a simple 1040 tax return. Yes, I think I invented TurboTax. 

But then came the summer internship. And one summer was all it took. I can still picture it pretty clearly. The computer programmers were buried in the basement of an office building, with no real sunlight, long hours in front of a blinking green screen, and I slowly started to resemble exactly what you would expect. Pale, frustrated, gaining weight, and wondering how I got there. It didn’t take long to realize this probably wasn’t my path.  But I did take something from that experience that has stuck with me ever since.

Garbage time

My boss for the internship had a saying that he used all the time. Garbage in, garbage out. You put in bad information, you get out bad answers.  Typically, this was the kind of thing you hear and move past. But it turns out it applies to a lot more than just programming and has always stuck with me.  If the inputs weren’t right, the output didn’t matter. In fact, it could look right while being completely wrong, which is probably worse.  Fast forward to today, and that same idea keeps coming back to me as I watch everything happening around AI.

Bracketology

You can’t go a day without hearing about it. ChatGPT, Claude, and a dozen others. There’s a lot of excitement, and if we’re being honest, a little bit of concern from people who wonder where it all leads or if it will replace them. So, I decided to test it in a way that felt familiar.

Instead of filling out my NCAA bracket the way I normally would, this year I asked AI to build one for me. I gave it pretty specific prompts. I wanted something that had a few well-placed early upsets (McNeese?).  I wanted a winner that wasn’t a number one seed, etc. (Iowa State?).  I wanted a chance to win but not be a clone of others.  It sounded reasonable, thoughtful even. It took a while, even longer than it should have, because it kept messing up the actual parings.  But I persevered, and we got it done.  But one day in?  I’m sitting at the bottom of our office pool.  Not middle of the pack, dead stinking last. Garbage in, garbage out. 

That doesn’t mean AI isn’t impressive because it is. It can do things quickly and at a scale that we haven’t seen before. It can help automate, organize, and take a lot of friction out of day-to-day work. But ultimately, it still depends on the inputs. More importantly, it depends on the understanding behind those inputs. And that’s where I think a lot of the conversation misses the mark, especially when it comes to financial advice.

Can you program subtlety?

I have said to many, AI doesn’t understand nuance. It doesn’t understand how someone feels about risk versus how they say they feel about risk or their capacity for risk. It doesn’t understand what it means when a client says they want a second home, but “has” to make sure their kids get through college without debt. Those tradeoffs aren’t always logical on paper, but they are very real in practice.

It also doesn’t pick up on the small things. Hesitation in a conversation or a change in tone. The story about how someone grew up around money (or didn’t) and the feelings that are ingrained. Those moments matter more than most people realize, and they rarely show up in clean inputs.

That’s why I don’t see AI as something to be worried about replacing advisors. I see it as something that good advisors will use to get better. There’s real value in using it to automate parts of the business, to take better notes, to create more consistency, and to free up time. But all of that should lead to more time spent where it actually matters, across the table and in real conversations. Understanding what really drives decisions.

Because at the end of the day, this has never just been about getting to the right answer. It’s about helping someone feel confident in the path they’re on, even when that path isn’t perfectly optimized. And that’s not something you can fully outsource.

I like AI. Even if it currently has me sitting at the very bottom of the bracket standings. It’s useful, it’s powerful, and it’s going to be part of how we all work going forward. But that old lesson still holds up.

Garbage in, garbage out.  When it comes to financial advice, the most important inputs are still human.

Similar Posts

  • How to Handle Clients’ Election Anxiety: A Guide for Financial Advisors

    Election seasons are often a time of heightened uncertainty for many investors, and financial advisors frequently find themselves on the front lines, addressing client concerns. Whether it’s a presidential election or midterm races, clients are often worried about how the outcomes might affect their portfolios and the economy at large. While these concerns are valid, it’s important for advisors to guide clients through these periods of anxiety with a steady, informed approach.
    Here are five strategies to help calm your clients’ election-related fears and keep them focused on their long-term goals.
    1. Emphasize Long-Term Investing
    Clients often fixate on short-term market volatility during election years, fearing that political outcomes will drastically affect their investments. However, research shows that market performance is rarely tied to the results of an election. As an advisor, your role is to remind clients that their portfolios are designed for the long term, and any temporary swings in the market are unlikely to derail their overall financial goals(FA Mag).
    Encouraging clients to focus on their financial plan and reminding them that markets have historically weathered political changes can help ease their anxiety. Provide examples of past market performance during election years, emphasizing that markets tend to stabilize over time, regardless of political shifts.
    2. Prepare for the Worst, but Plan for the Best
    While it’s true that elections can introduce uncertainty, it’s essential to avoid a reactionary approach. Instead, help clients plan for a range of possible scenarios without making drastic changes to their investment strategy. For instance, rather than selling off stocks in anticipation of a market downturn, encourage them to stick to their long-term asset allocation(FA Mag).
    Building a plan that includes both potential risks and opportunities can give clients confidence. Offer them stress-testing scenarios, showing how their portfolios might perform under various market conditions. This approach can demonstrate that their investment plan is resilient enough to withstand potential volatility.
    3. Maintain Frequent Communication
    Clear, consistent communication is crucial during periods of heightened anxiety. Proactively reach out to clients with updates on how the election might impact the economy and markets. Provide them with balanced, data-driven insights rather than feeding into media-driven fears(Wealth Management).
    Regularly scheduled check-ins—via email, phone calls, or virtual meetings—can reassure clients that you’re keeping a close eye on the situation and that there’s no need for rash decisions. Even a quick update on the markets or sharing an article about historical market performance during elections can help clients feel more in control.
    4. Focus on What You Can Control
    As much as elections bring uncertainty, there are many factors that both you and your clients can control. Encourage clients to focus on elements within their control, such as their savings rate, spending habits, and asset allocation. Remind them that while political outcomes are unpredictable, their ability to stay disciplined and follow their financial plan remains within their hands(Wealth Management).
    By shifting the conversation from uncontrollable external events to personal financial habits, clients can regain a sense of empowerment. This also prevents them from making impulsive decisions based on election results or market reactions.
    5. Highlight Historical Resilience
    History provides ample evidence that financial markets are resilient in the face of political changes. Over the past century, markets have survived wars, recessions, and numerous elections with vastly different political outcomes. In most cases, the economy and markets recover, and those who remain invested tend to benefit from long-term growth(ThinkAdvisor).
    Share historical data with clients to illustrate how markets have performed during previous election cycles. This can offer a helpful perspective, calming nerves and reinforcing the idea that short-term volatility is part of the investing journey.
    Conclusion: Stay the Course
    For financial advisors, election seasons can be an opportunity to demonstrate the value of a sound financial plan and steady guidance. While it’s natural for clients to feel nervous about the potential impacts of political outcomes, your role is to keep them focused on their long-term goals, grounded in facts, and committed to their investment strategy.
    By emphasizing long-term thinking, maintaining regular communication, and highlighting market resilience, you can help clients navigate the election cycle with confidence. In times of uncertainty, staying the course is often the best strategy.
    In the end, elections come and go, but a well-thought-out financial plan is built to last.

  • Keeping Clients Calm When Markets Are Volatile

    Keeping Clients Calm When Markets Are Volatile Market volatility is nothing new, but in today’s fast-changing world, it feels more intense than ever. As a financial advisor, your job isn’t just to manage portfolios; it’s to guide, educate, and reassure clients when markets become unpredictable. How you communicate and lead during these moments can define…